Human rights and IoT – looking for a win-win solution – WS 05 2017: Difference between revisions

From EuroDIG Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
No edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:
<big>'''Human rights and IoT: looking for a win-win solution'''</big> – WS 05 2017
7 June 2017 | 11:00 - 12:30 | Ballroom II, Swissotel, Tallinn, Estonia | [[image:Icon_remote_20px.png | remote participation | link=Programme_overview_2017]] | [[image:Icons_live_20px.png | live streaming | link=Programme_overview_2017]]<br />
[[Programme overview 2017| Programme overview '''wiki''']] | [https://www.eurodig.org/index.php?id=707 Programme overview '''EuroDIG web site''']


[[Programme overview 2017]]
{{Sessionadvice01}}
== Session teaser ==
== Session teaser ==
''The Internet of Things - pervasive, connected devices - reaches into our daily lives with unprecedented intimacy. It offers new ways to tackle societal challenges and new economic opportunities - yet what is the Human Rights' perspective?''
''The Internet of Things - pervasive, connected devices - reaches into our daily lives with unprecedented intimacy. It offers new ways to tackle societal challenges and new economic opportunities - yet what is the Human Rights' perspective?''
Line 15: Line 14:


The Internet of Things (IoT) is a combination of protocols and applications, embodied in hard- and software that is opening the doors to exciting new opportunities and innovation, but is also resulting in pressing questions which needs to be answered including:
The Internet of Things (IoT) is a combination of protocols and applications, embodied in hard- and software that is opening the doors to exciting new opportunities and innovation, but is also resulting in pressing questions which needs to be answered including:
1. IoT is extending the Internet to many “Things” that collect and share information and/or act, based on information collected and/or triggered by people. Who is accountable for what?  
# IoT is extending the Internet to many “Things” that collect and share information and/or act, based on information collected and/or triggered by people. Who is accountable for what?<br />a) Who pays for the development and deployment of IoT ecosystems when the commercial application is not feasible but the societal need is high;<br />b) If harm results from IoT ecosystems, who “pays” for it?  
a- Who pays for the development and deployment of IoT ecosystems when the commercial application is not feasible but the societal need is high;
# What is the role of standard setting bodies, the technical community, civil society, governments and and the private sector, in order to help realize a sustainable and trusted IoT ecosystem that supports both commercial applications as non-commercial applications that help address societal challenges?
b- If harm results from IoT ecosystems, who “pays” for it?  
# How can the world achieve a trusted IoT ecosystem when it comes to security and privacy online?
2. What is the role of standard setting bodies, the technical community, civil society, governments and and the private sector, in order to help realize a sustainable and trusted IoT ecosystem that supports both commercial applications as non-commercial applications that help address societal challenges?
3. How can the world achieve a trusted IoT ecosystem when it comes to security and privacy online?


The workshop will discuss the IoT ecosystem from different perspectives quoting examples from Europe and beyond.  It will be informed by the work done in IGF context by the Dynamic Coalition on the Internet of Things that has been active since the IGF 2008 in Hyderabad and has presented a document on Global Good Practice for IoT from a multi-stakeholder perspective. The results of this panel will feed into the global IGF 2017 session of the DC IoT.
The workshop will discuss the IoT ecosystem from different perspectives quoting examples from Europe and beyond.  It will be informed by the work done in IGF context by the Dynamic Coalition on the Internet of Things that has been active since the IGF 2008 in Hyderabad and has presented a document on Global Good Practice for IoT from a multi-stakeholder perspective. The results of this panel will feed into the global IGF 2017 session of the DC IoT.
Line 30: Line 27:


== People ==  
== People ==  
'''Please provide name and institution for all people you list here.'''
*'''Focal Point:''' Maarten Botterman, GNKS Consult [mailto:maarten@gnksconsult.com maarten@gnksconsult.com]
*'''Focal Point:''' Maarten Botterman, GNKS Consult [mailto:maarten@gnksconsult.com maarten@gnksconsult.com]
Focal Points take over the responsibility and lead of the session organisation. Focal Points are kindly requested to observe [http://www.eurodig.org/get-involved/organising-a-session/#jfmulticontent_c2865-1 EuroDIG's session principles]. Focal Points work in close cooperation with the respective Subject Matter Expert (SME) and the EuroDIG Secretariat.
 
 
*'''Subject Matter Expert (SME):''' Farzaneh Badeii (Internet Governance Project - Georgia Tech)
*'''Subject Matter Expert (SME):''' Farzaneh Badeii (Internet Governance Project - Georgia Tech)
SMEs are responsible for the clustering of submissions into a thematic category they have an expertise in. They define subtopics and identify submissions which fall under this subtopic. The aim is to verify submissions which can be merged in one session. In the course of the session organising process SMEs will serve as a mentor for the respective category by supporting all Focal Points.
*'''Key Participants (for workshop) or Panellists (for plenary)'''
Short introductions will be provided by (confirmed speakers only):


Jari Arkko (technical community) is  an Expert on Internet Architecture with Ericsson Research in Jorvas, Finland. At the IETF, he served six years as one of the Internet Area Directors in the Internet Engineering Steering Group (IESG) and one year as a member of the IAB. From March 2013 he is serving as the General Area Director and IETF Chair. Jari has published 36 RFCs, including specifications for Mobile IPv6, EAP-AKA, Diameter, SEND, and various IPv6 related documents. He has previously served as a chair of three IETF working groups. Jari has also served in the Technical Advisory Board for the IP Smart Objects Alliance (IPSO) and works in a number of research projects at Ericsson. In the past, Jari has worked in the implementation of routers, VPN software, testing tools, modem banks, cellular network nodes, AAA systems, compilers, and AI systems. He received his Licentiate’s degree from Helsinki University of Technology in 1996. Jari’s main interests in the Internet include architecture, IPv6, small implementations, the Internet of Things, social media, Internet governance, and cutting through hype that often surrounds some aspects of our technology. He likes to build and and use the technology that he works with. For instance, he moved to an IPv6-only network in 2010 and builds smart home networks as a hobby. He frequently communicates with his laundry on Facebook. [mailto:jari.arkko@piuha.net jari.arkko@piuha.net]


Peter Kimpian (government)is currently working at the Data Protection Unit of the Council of Europe as national expert being seconded by the Hungarian Data Protection and Freedom of Information Authority. Working as an international privacy and data protection expert for the last 6 years Peter has been a member of subgroups of Article 29 Working Party, of JSB Europol, CSG Schengen and other alike organisations. Being in charge at the national data protection authority mainly with international privacy and data protection issues related to cooperation in law enforcement sector and national security he has been involved as data protection expert in issues among others like EU PNR Agreements with third states, EU PNR Directive, TFTP Agreement, regulation on drones and Privacy Shield agreement. At the Council of Europe he is carrying on dossiers related to internet governance, domain names’ related privacy issues, data protection in law enforcement sector and the modernisation of convention 108. [mailto:Peter.KIMPIAN@coe.int Peter.KIMPIAN@coe.int]
*'''Key Participants''' <br />Short introductions will be provided for confirmed speakers only:
**'''Jari Arkko (technical community)''' is  an Expert on Internet Architecture with Ericsson Research in Jorvas, Finland. At the IETF, he served six years as one of the Internet Area Directors in the Internet Engineering Steering Group (IESG) and one year as a member of the IAB. From March 2013 he is serving as the General Area Director and IETF Chair. Jari has published 36 RFCs, including specifications for Mobile IPv6, EAP-AKA, Diameter, SEND, and various IPv6 related documents. He has previously served as a chair of three IETF working groups. Jari has also served in the Technical Advisory Board for the IP Smart Objects Alliance (IPSO) and works in a number of research projects at Ericsson. In the past, Jari has worked in the implementation of routers, VPN software, testing tools, modem banks, cellular network nodes, AAA systems, compilers, and AI systems. He received his Licentiate’s degree from Helsinki University of Technology in 1996. Jari’s main interests in the Internet include architecture, IPv6, small implementations, the Internet of Things, social media, Internet governance, and cutting through hype that often surrounds some aspects of our technology. He likes to build and and use the technology that he works with. For instance, he moved to an IPv6-only network in 2010 and builds smart home networks as a hobby. He frequently communicates with his laundry on Facebook. [mailto:jari.arkko@piuha.net jari.arkko@piuha.net]
**'''Peter Kimpian (government)''' is currently working at the Data Protection Unit of the Council of Europe as national expert being seconded by the Hungarian Data Protection and Freedom of Information Authority. Working as an international privacy and data protection expert for the last 6 years Peter has been a member of subgroups of Article 29 Working Party, of JSB Europol, CSG Schengen and other alike organisations. Being in charge at the national data protection authority mainly with international privacy and data protection issues related to cooperation in law enforcement sector and national security he has been involved as data protection expert in issues among others like EU PNR Agreements with third states, EU PNR Directive, TFTP Agreement, regulation on drones and Privacy Shield agreement. At the Council of Europe he is carrying on dossiers related to internet governance, domain names’ related privacy issues, data protection in law enforcement sector and the modernisation of convention 108. [mailto:Peter.KIMPIAN@coe.int Peter.KIMPIAN@coe.int]
**'''Alison Harcourt (research)''' specialises in regulatory change in communications markets. She is interested in solutions to regulatory problems based around the citizen/consumer and/or civil society voice. She has written on the regulation of traditional and new media markets at EU and international levels contributing to the literature on agenda setting, regulatory competition, soft governance, Europeanisation, policy transfer and policy convergence. Currently, Alison is PI on the ESRC funded project 'International Professional Fora: a study in civil society participation in internet governance' (September 2015 - September 2018) [mailto:A.Harcourt@exeter.ac.uk A.Harcourt@exeter.ac.uk]<br />Setting standards is crucial in moving forward with IoT, and in the end a means to keep te overall “costs” (in the broadest sense of the word) as low as possible. Alison will cover standard developing organisation activity in the field of IoT drawing on research from an ESRC project. It outlines the number of SDO fora working on IoT which number over 150 then focuses on the work of the IEEE, W3C and IETF, namely the IEEE’s P2413 group, the IETF’s LPWAN and Thing-to-Thing T2T WF and the W3C’s Web of Things WG, with examples from home utilities monitoring, smart farming and connected cars.


Alison Harcourt (research) specialises in regulatory change in communications markets. She is interested in solutions to regulatory problems based around the citizen/consumer and/or civil society voice. She has written on the regulation of traditional and new media markets at EU and international levels contributing to the literature on agenda setting, regulatory competition, soft governance, Europeanisation, policy transfer and policy convergence. Currently, Alison is PI on the ESRC funded project 'International Professional Fora: a study in civil society participation in internet governance' (September 2015 - September 2018) [mailto:A.Harcourt@exeter.ac.uk A.Harcourt@exeter.ac.uk]
*'''Moderator'''<br />Maarten Botterman will be moderating this session. <br />Maarten Botterman is Director of ICANN, Chairman of the IGF Dynamic Coalition on the Internet of Things, and Chairman of the Supervisory Board of NLnet Foundation. As independent authority on future Internet and Internet Governance matters he combines insight in new technology potential with user interests to develop strategic opportunities for policy and businesses. He builds on experience as former Director at RAND Corporation (European Office), Scientific Officer European Commission, and Senior Advisor/Head of Unit at the Dutch Ministry of Transport.  
Setting standards in crucial in moving forward with IoT, and in the end a means to keep te overall “costs” (in the broadest sense of the word) as low as possible. Alison will cover standard developing organisation activity in the field of IoT drawing on research from an ESRC project. It outlines the number of SDO fora working on IoT which number over 150 then focuses on the work of the IEEE, W3C and IETF, namely the IEEE’s P2413 group, the IETF’s LPWAN and Thing-to-Thing T2T WF and the W3C’s Web of Things WG, with examples from home utilities monitoring, smart farming and connected cars.


*'''Moderator'''
*'''Remote Moderator'''<br />Rachel Pollack will be the remote moderator of this session.
Maarten Botterman will be moderating this session.  


Maarten Botterman is Director of ICANN, Chairman of the IGF Dynamic Coalition on the Internet of Things, and Chairman of the Supervisory Board of NLnet Foundation. As independent authority on future Internet and Internet Governance matters he combines insight in new technology potential with user interests to develop strategic opportunities for policy and businesses. He builds on experience as former Director at RAND Corporation (European Office), Scientific Officer European Commission, and Senior Advisor/Head of Unit at the Dutch Ministry of Transport.  
*'''Organising Team (Org Team)'''
*'''Remote Moderator'''
**Alison Harcourt [mailto:A.Harcourt@exeter.ac.uk A.Harcourt@exeter.ac.uk]
Rachel Pollack will be the remote moderator of this session.
**Farzaneh Badii  [mailto:farzaneh.badii@gmail.com farzaneh.badii@gmail.com]
**Maarten Botterman [mailto:maarten@gnksconsult.com maarten@gnksconsult.com]
**Matei-Eugen Vasile [mailto:matei.vasile@apti.ro matei.vasile@apti.ro]
**Matthias Spielkamp [mailto:ms@irights.info ms@irights.info]
**Rachel Pollack [mailto:Rachel.l.pollack@gmail.com Rachel.l.pollack@gmail.com]
**Robin Wilton - Internet Society [mailto:wilton@isoc.org wilton@isoc.org]
**Valentina Hvale Pellizer [mailto:valentina@oneworldplatform.net valentina@oneworldplatform.net]
**Zakir Syed [mailto:zakirbinrehman@yahoo.com zakirbinrehman@yahoo.com]


The Remote Moderator is in charge of facilitating participation via digital channels such as WebEx and social medial (Twitter, facebook). Remote Moderators monitor and moderate the social media channels and the participants via WebEX and forward questions to the session moderator.
*'''Organising Team (Org Team)'''
Alison Harcourt [mailto: A.Harcourt@exeter.ac.uk A.Harcourt@exeter.ac.uk]
Farzaneh Badii  [mailto: farzaneh.badii@gmail.com farzaneh.badii@gmail.com]
Maarten Botterman [mailto: maarten@gnksconsult.com maarten@gnksconsult.com]
Matei-Eugen Vasile [mailto: matei.vasile@apti.ro matei.vasile@apti.ro]
Matthias Spielkamp [mailto: ms@irights.info ms@irights.info]
Rachel Pollack  [mailto: Rachel.l.pollack@gmail.com Rachel.l.pollack@gmail.com]
Robin Wilton - Internet Society [mailto:wilton@isoc.org wilton@isoc.org]
Valentina Hvale Pellizer [mailto: valentina@oneworldplatform.net valentina@oneworldplatform.net]
Zakir Syed [mailto: zakirbinrehman@yahoo.com zakirbinrehman@yahoo.com]
*'''Reporter'''
*'''Reporter'''
'''Until 15 May 2017.''' The Reporter takes notes during the session and formulates 3 (max. 5) bullet points at the end of each session that:
*are summarised on a slide and  presented to the audience at the end of each session
*relate to the particular session and to European Internet governance policy
*are forward looking and propose goals and activities that can be initiated after EuroDIG (recommendations)
*are in (rough) consensus with the audience
*are to be submitted to the secretariat within 48 hours after the session took place
Please provide short CV of the reporter of your session at the Wiki or link to another source and contact the [mailto:office@eurodig.org EuroDIG secretariat] if you need help to find a reporter.


== Current discussion, conference calls, schedules and minutes ==
== Current discussion, conference calls, schedules and minutes ==
See the [[{{TALKPAGENAME}} | discussion]] tab on the upper left side of this page. Please use this page to publish:
See the [[{{TALKPAGENAME}} | discussion]] tab on the upper left side of this page.  
*dates for virtual meetings or coordination calls
*short summary of calls or email exchange
Please be as open and transparent as possible in order to allow others to get involved and contact you. Use the wiki not only as the place to publish results but also to summarize the discussion process.


== Contact ==  
== Contact ==  

Revision as of 16:11, 26 May 2017

7 June 2017 | 11:00 - 12:30 | Ballroom II, Swissotel, Tallinn, Estonia | remote participation | live streaming
Programme overview wiki | Programme overview EuroDIG web site

Session teaser

The Internet of Things - pervasive, connected devices - reaches into our daily lives with unprecedented intimacy. It offers new ways to tackle societal challenges and new economic opportunities - yet what is the Human Rights' perspective?

Keywords

Human Rights, Internet of Things, privacy, accountability, responsibility

Session description

The Internet of Things (IoT) continues to develop rapidly. Cisco estimates that by 2020, there will be 50 billion Internet-connected devices. IoT devices ranging from health monitoring devices to smart thermostats and smart toothbrushes have become increasingly embedded in our everyday lives. What effect does the spread of IoT have on our own privacy and autonomy, and that of the people around us? How can data protection principles such as consent and limited purpose apply in a world of pervasive connected devices?

IoT It also offers new opportunities for innovation that help us address societal challenges such as early warning systems for natural disasters and IoT-enabled ecosystems that support people to continue living independently much longer than would be possible without those tools. In this way, IoT not only poses a risk to the right to privacy, but also an opportunity to work towards the fulfillment of other human rights, such as the right to health. How does IoT enable human rights and further sustainable development? And how is it changing our assumptions about self, self-determination and self-fulfilment? Our panel of experts will give technical, ethical and practical perspectives on this theme, which affects the lives of all of us.

The Internet of Things (IoT) is a combination of protocols and applications, embodied in hard- and software that is opening the doors to exciting new opportunities and innovation, but is also resulting in pressing questions which needs to be answered including:

  1. IoT is extending the Internet to many “Things” that collect and share information and/or act, based on information collected and/or triggered by people. Who is accountable for what?
    a) Who pays for the development and deployment of IoT ecosystems when the commercial application is not feasible but the societal need is high;
    b) If harm results from IoT ecosystems, who “pays” for it?
  2. What is the role of standard setting bodies, the technical community, civil society, governments and and the private sector, in order to help realize a sustainable and trusted IoT ecosystem that supports both commercial applications as non-commercial applications that help address societal challenges?
  3. How can the world achieve a trusted IoT ecosystem when it comes to security and privacy online?

The workshop will discuss the IoT ecosystem from different perspectives quoting examples from Europe and beyond. It will be informed by the work done in IGF context by the Dynamic Coalition on the Internet of Things that has been active since the IGF 2008 in Hyderabad and has presented a document on Global Good Practice for IoT from a multi-stakeholder perspective. The results of this panel will feed into the global IGF 2017 session of the DC IoT.

Format

3-4 very short presentations and a moderated discussion opening the floor to all EuroDIG participants around the questions posted above, leading to messages concerning different issues arising related to IoT and human rights for the discussants to debate and agree or disagree.We look for an open discussion engaging and involving all stakeholders.

Further reading

Main page of IGF Dynamic Coalition on IoT

People


  • Subject Matter Expert (SME): Farzaneh Badeii (Internet Governance Project - Georgia Tech)


  • Key Participants
    Short introductions will be provided for confirmed speakers only:
    • Jari Arkko (technical community) is an Expert on Internet Architecture with Ericsson Research in Jorvas, Finland. At the IETF, he served six years as one of the Internet Area Directors in the Internet Engineering Steering Group (IESG) and one year as a member of the IAB. From March 2013 he is serving as the General Area Director and IETF Chair. Jari has published 36 RFCs, including specifications for Mobile IPv6, EAP-AKA, Diameter, SEND, and various IPv6 related documents. He has previously served as a chair of three IETF working groups. Jari has also served in the Technical Advisory Board for the IP Smart Objects Alliance (IPSO) and works in a number of research projects at Ericsson. In the past, Jari has worked in the implementation of routers, VPN software, testing tools, modem banks, cellular network nodes, AAA systems, compilers, and AI systems. He received his Licentiate’s degree from Helsinki University of Technology in 1996. Jari’s main interests in the Internet include architecture, IPv6, small implementations, the Internet of Things, social media, Internet governance, and cutting through hype that often surrounds some aspects of our technology. He likes to build and and use the technology that he works with. For instance, he moved to an IPv6-only network in 2010 and builds smart home networks as a hobby. He frequently communicates with his laundry on Facebook. jari.arkko@piuha.net
    • Peter Kimpian (government) is currently working at the Data Protection Unit of the Council of Europe as national expert being seconded by the Hungarian Data Protection and Freedom of Information Authority. Working as an international privacy and data protection expert for the last 6 years Peter has been a member of subgroups of Article 29 Working Party, of JSB Europol, CSG Schengen and other alike organisations. Being in charge at the national data protection authority mainly with international privacy and data protection issues related to cooperation in law enforcement sector and national security he has been involved as data protection expert in issues among others like EU PNR Agreements with third states, EU PNR Directive, TFTP Agreement, regulation on drones and Privacy Shield agreement. At the Council of Europe he is carrying on dossiers related to internet governance, domain names’ related privacy issues, data protection in law enforcement sector and the modernisation of convention 108. Peter.KIMPIAN@coe.int
    • Alison Harcourt (research) specialises in regulatory change in communications markets. She is interested in solutions to regulatory problems based around the citizen/consumer and/or civil society voice. She has written on the regulation of traditional and new media markets at EU and international levels contributing to the literature on agenda setting, regulatory competition, soft governance, Europeanisation, policy transfer and policy convergence. Currently, Alison is PI on the ESRC funded project 'International Professional Fora: a study in civil society participation in internet governance' (September 2015 - September 2018) A.Harcourt@exeter.ac.uk
      Setting standards is crucial in moving forward with IoT, and in the end a means to keep te overall “costs” (in the broadest sense of the word) as low as possible. Alison will cover standard developing organisation activity in the field of IoT drawing on research from an ESRC project. It outlines the number of SDO fora working on IoT which number over 150 then focuses on the work of the IEEE, W3C and IETF, namely the IEEE’s P2413 group, the IETF’s LPWAN and Thing-to-Thing T2T WF and the W3C’s Web of Things WG, with examples from home utilities monitoring, smart farming and connected cars.
  • Moderator
    Maarten Botterman will be moderating this session.
    Maarten Botterman is Director of ICANN, Chairman of the IGF Dynamic Coalition on the Internet of Things, and Chairman of the Supervisory Board of NLnet Foundation. As independent authority on future Internet and Internet Governance matters he combines insight in new technology potential with user interests to develop strategic opportunities for policy and businesses. He builds on experience as former Director at RAND Corporation (European Office), Scientific Officer European Commission, and Senior Advisor/Head of Unit at the Dutch Ministry of Transport.
  • Remote Moderator
    Rachel Pollack will be the remote moderator of this session.
  • Reporter

Current discussion, conference calls, schedules and minutes

See the discussion tab on the upper left side of this page.

Contact

Get in contact with the Org Team by sending an email.

Video record

Will be provided here after the event.

Transcript

Will be provided here after the event.

Messages

Please provide a short summary from the outcome of your session. Bullet points are fine.